How Safe Is Samui? - April 2020 Update Including Koh Phangan
|Koh Samui 2016. Boy saved with CPR and vinegar after near-fatal box jellyfish sting.|
So how safe is Koh Samui? There's been plenty of confusion and panic. Is it OK to swim? How many of these 'killer jellyfish' are there? Where are they? What do they look like? How big is the risk? What do I do if I get stung? Here is the original guide, followed by a April 2020 update. The risk remains.
The local authorities, if this is accurate, report of 12 box jellyfish stings around Koh Samui for the year up to October, 2015 including the death of a 20-year old German woman. These stings have occurred at Chaweng, Lamai, Mae Nam, Lipa Noi and on Ang Thong island. Nearby Koh Phangan also reports stings including two fatalities in the past 12 months.
While there is of course a problem and ignoring signs is plain stupid, there is no need to panic. Be vigilant, ask questions, use common sense, take precautions and heed the warning signs (unlike the couple in the photo below putting themselves at serious risk the day after a death at this beach - if it had been a shark attack fatality and the sign said 'Killer Shark. Very Dangerous' they'd be having that drink in the pool). Also note that day or night, there is always a risk.
Somewhere in the figure of 500,000 visit Koh Samui every year. The equation could be simplified guessing that if half enter the sea for a swim or snorkel then the risk, based on 12 stings this year, would be around 1 in 15,000. Being killed by a jellyfish? 1 in 180,000. This is not to trivialise the problem as the truth is, that '1' could be you!
We take proper precautions (or should) when riding a motor bike, walking across the street, using a power tool, jumping out of a plane, whatever. So to not be that '1' we wear a helmet and follow the rules, look to the left-right and make sure the road is clear, use protective eyewear and gloves, wear a parachute! Accidents will happen but taking the right precautions will minimise the risk.
The same goes with the threat of being stung by a box jellyfish. If you wear a protective lycra suit when entering the water your chances of being stung are almost nothing. Just about every marine biologist entering tropical seas wears a suit because they know better; they choose life, not a tan. Get the suntan on the sand, wear a suit in the sea. There's plenty of info on this blog about suits.Further Reading:
Carry a cheap bottle of vinegar in your beach bag. If there is a sting, immediately splash the sting area with vinegar. Do not try and remove the tentacles - don't touch them. Use CPR if the victim requires it. After around 30 seconds of splashing vinegar, the tentacle's stinging cells will be de-activated and you can remove them with seawater. Immediately seek medical assistance.Further Reading:
Unfortunately, little is known about exactly where box jellyfish are in Thailand or if there is a season where they are more common. Research is minimal. No-one knows for certain about what species of box jellyfish is causing the damage. It is a big one. It has multiple tentacles, is highly toxic and is possibly related to Australia's notorious Chironex Fleckeri.
[Postscript 2017: scientific research has increased in the area and it is now known that a deadly species of Chironex box jellyfish that is native to Thailand lives in Samui waters and is responsible for serious and fatal stings. Chironex indrasaksajiae Sucharitakul sp..]
So whether it is Chaweng or Lamai beach or anywhere else along the Samui coast, it seems there is box jellyfish habitat. How many are there? No-one knows. What is known is that box jellyfish can swim (not float) at a speed of around 3 knots. They are brainless but have a visual system of navigation (eyes with retinas, lenses, corneas) that guide them past obstacles such as rocks, nets and slow-moving human legs. They are almost completely transparent so very difficult to see in the water even if it is clear. They hunt for small fish and shrimp in very shallow, sandy-bottom water close to the shore. The media often refers to a jellyfish 'attack' but all human stings are accidental. It is unsuspecting people making contact with the jellyfish, not vica-versa.
So is it safe to swim at Koh Samui - or for that matter in other coastal areas of Thailand. The answer is not a simple yes or no. The risk remains no different now than what it was 6 months or 6 years ago. Thousands of happy holiday makers have come and gone leaving with nothing worse than sunburn.
If a sign warning of 'Dangerous Jellyfish' is at one beach and not another, does this mean the beach with no sign is safer? No. The sign just tells us what we already know. Somewhere out there are box jellyfish. The temporarily signed beach might have had a recent sting and common sense would say 'stay out of the water' for at least a day or two.
What is needed is a permanent plan to inform visitors and minimize the risk. Would the German woman killed this week have chosen to swim at night had she been better informed about the risk? And the Koh Phangan deaths - would the Thai woman have done the same, or would the parents of the 5-year old boy let him play in the shallows without a protective suit if they had known? It's hypothetical but at least they would have been better positioned to make a decision.
Permanent warning and information signs plus vinegar stations strategically placed around the island are the frontline of defence against further pain and tragedy. It works in Australia. Waiting for the storm to blow over and continue as normal until the next serious sting does not. It has not worked and will not work. There are other islands and beaches in Thailand that have implemented box jellyfish safety systems - Phuket, Koh Chang, Koh Mak, Koh Lipe - and their tourist numbers have not gone down. People still enjoy spending time in the sea. They are informed, make a choice and have vinegar right there on the beach just in case. There are reports of success and lives being saved.
Koh Samui is at a crossroads. The path forward for this popular resort island is written large on the signs that have been posted with every box jellyfish sting experienced over many years. The local tourism and hospitality operators and the island's authorities have for too long gone in the wrong direction; ignoring expert advice, dismissing damning statistics, failing in their duty of care and hoping the problem would just go away. Well, it hasn't and it won't. Box jellyfish are here to stay and the time to do something about it is now.
UPDATE APRIL, 2020:
There were a number of serious stings with CPR involved at Chaweng mid-November 2019. All victims which included children were admitted to hospital. One of the young victims received terrible stings and was lucky to survive. He was air-lifted to Bangkok in an induced coma. Koh Phangan also in this period reported stings.
LINK November 2019 Koh Samui Stings
Thai media reported on 30 October, 2019 that a 10-year old Russian male was stung by a box jellyfish in the morning while swimming at Lamai beach. The boy was immediately attended to by the emergency rescue team and rushed to hospital where he was treated and kept in for observation overnight.
|Highly venomous box jellyfish collected in the Lamai beach area July 2018|
Official Koh Phangan Warning - September 2018:
INCASE OF AN EMERGENCY CALL 1669# (Jellyfish stings on Koh Samui and Koh Phangan only).
At the time of this update there have been no recently reported deaths in this corner of the Gulf of Thailand though there have been reports of box jellyfish sightings, specimen collections and stings requiring hospitalisation. Deadly box jellyfish are present and the risk remains real.
In mid-2017, two stinger prevention nets were installed at Koh Samui. One is located at Lamai Beach and the second was installed at Chaweng Beach. At 100m long and 7 metres deep, these nets have been tested by local authorities and are believed to be safe. Unfortunately though, the net at Chaweng has been permanently removed. This is an initiative of Thailand's Marine & Coastal Resources Department (in conjunction with the Koh Samui Municipality and Koh Samui Tourism Association) who have been monitoring the nets' effectiveness. Please observe warning and information signs.
NOTE: Having been removed for maintenance, the net at Lamai was re-installed on 4 July 2019 for what local authorities believe is a 6-month box jellyfish 'epidemic season'. Stings have however already been reported starting July 2019.
Staff of Thailand's Marine & Coastal Resources Department conduct regular (not sure how regular) sweeps with nets in the shallows of certain popular Samui beaches. Wearing full body lycra stinger suits and rubber gloves as protection, they continue to catch the lethal Chironex-type box jellyfish.
Koh Phangan has experienced severe box jellyfish stings including deaths in recent years. The deadly Chironex species are still being caught during collections by marine biologists and support staff at various locations around the island. Authorities and volunteer locals have responded to this situation and warning signs, vinegar poles with first aid instructions plus vinegar stocked SLS stations are scattered around the island. Many locals have been trained by Thai Health Department & marine services staff. A huge prevention net is located at Haad Rin beach. Note that the vinegar may be coloured with food dye to try and deter idiots from stealing it!
An official warning was issued September 2018 by the Governor of Surat Thani to avoid swimming at Chalok Lam Bay, Koh Phangan after a large number of box jellyfish sightings.
NOTE: Having been removed for maintenance, the net at Haad Rin was re-installed on 4 July 2019 for what local authorities believe is a 6-month box jellyfish 'epidemic season'.
|Box jellyfish sting Lamai 10 August 2018 - Source Thaivisa|
|Box jellyfish sting Lamai 10 August 2018 - Source Thaivisa|
PLEASE NOTE if you or someone gets a sting:
2. TREAT THE VICTIM - use CPR if needed to keep the victim alive if not breathing and/or no pulse
3. TREAT THE STING - apply vinegar by pouring on sting area for 30-60 seconds
4. TRANSPORT - get the victim to hospital or the doctor as soon as possible
Camille Lemmens is a diving instructor and long-time resident of Koh Samui. He is a strong advocate for water safety in Thailand and is actively working with the local community and authorities to improve box jellyfish awareness and safety. Check out Camille's Samui Info Blog to get the latest on Box Jellyfish activities including Prevention and Treatment Seminars during 2017.